Why Two Experts Can Reach Different Values
Many valuations rest on a simple two variable equation. While the equation itself is simple, arriving at an opinion of value involves complicated analyses and due diligence. Almost every disagreement between experts traces back to how each one selected these two variables.
EBITDA×Multiplier = Business Value
Variable 1
Where EBITDA Differs
Owner's compensation left unadjusted
A private company's CEO is often paid above or below fair market rate. If an expert does not restate that salary to what an arm's-length replacement would cost, earnings, and therefore the valuation opinions, are overstated or understated before the multiplier is even applied.
Incomplete add-backs for perquisites
Personal vehicles, family payroll, travel, and other non-business expenses run through the company need to be added back to normalize earnings. An expert who catches only some of them understates true cash flow — and every dollar missed is compounded by the multiplier.
Variable 2
Where the Multiplier Differs
Wrong dataset, wrong company
A multiple drawn from transactions of large, publicly traded, multi-billion-dollar companies reflects their scale, liquidity, and access to capital — not the risk profile of a private company with $10 million in revenue.
Size and risk go unadjusted
Smaller private companies often carry thinner management depth, customer concentration, and no public market for their stock. A multiplier selected from multi-billion-dollar public companies ignores this mismatch.
Illustration — same company, two opinions
Expert A
Adjusted EBITDA $2.0M (includes fair owner’s compensation adjustment and perks add-backs)
Multiplier applied 4× (selected from low middle market private company business sales)
Value $8.0M
vs.
Expert B
Incomplete Adjusted EBITDA $2.5M (does not include a fair market owner’s compensation adjustment)
Multiplier applied 7.0×
Value $15M
A $0.5M gap in earnings and a 3× gap in multiplier
— both defensible-sounding on their own — produce a $8M in valuation conclusions.
Two experts rarely disagree about the formula. They disagree about what goes into it — and that is exactly where a valuation report should be read most closely.
Before accepting a valuation opinion, ask how owner's compensation was adjusted, which add-backs were included, and whether the comparable transactions match the size and risk of the business.
For further information and advice, contact Thomas at:




Comments